Wisdom for Every Trial
James Bible Study
The Trial of Presuming Tomorrow
Derek has made big plans for his business to grow. He spent a couple of weeks at the beginning of the year planning how to make that happen. He worked his plans down to the day for the whole year. Today, he plans to attend several meetings throughout the city he lives in. The day starts, and Derek gets caught in traffic. He sits in his car twiddling his thumbs instead of driving to his first meeting.
He finally gets to his first two meetings of the day. It is lunchtime, and he goes to a local deli. He is standing in line with the person in front of him turns and I, “How is your day going?” He responds, Not completely as I planned. I was late to a couple of meetings this morning because of traffic. How about you?”
“I try not to feel my day with a ton of things. I used to double book myself a lot, but all that led to a stress. Nowadays, I leave buffers between like events and activities. I have also learned that those buffers become times where I can do what God wants me to do. Speaking of, can I pray for you?”
Derek’s palms started to sweat. He has been a Christian for a while, but he never considered God ministering through him while he was at work were busy during the day. “Sure.” He tells the man how he is always so busy and would like prayer for time to rest and get more involved in his church.
American Christians have trouble with leaving time to wait on the Lord and in their faith. But James has bigger issues to address. He wants to talk about how we live like functional atheists because we do not realize God gives us life and breath. He wants to be involved in our lives and schedules. We often do not consider God’s will or take our plans to Him. James wants us to not just go through the motions, but realize that how we live much of the time does not leave room for God.
James 4:13-17
13 Come now, you who say, “Today or tomorrow, we will go to this city or that city, and we will spend a year there, and we will do business, and we will profit.” 14 What? You do not know about your life tomorrow, for it you are a vapor that appears for a short time, but then disappears. 15 Instead, you should say, “If the Lord wills, we will live and do this or that.” 16 But now, you are boasting in your arrogant plans—all such boasting is evil. 17 Therefore, for the one who knows the right thing to do and does not do it, to him it is sin.
Thought Flow
James grabs the attention of merchants who plan without considering God’s will or that they will not be able to complete their plans. They are looking for ways to profit in different cities, making plans for a whole year. He reminds them that they do not even know what tomorrow holds, let alone a year from now. The solution is to do things as God wills, to consider God in their plans. They should not be arrogant and boast about making profit and traveling as they wish. We must consider doing the things we know are right to do, or we are in sin.
Surrounding Context
In the paragraph before this one, James addresses worldliness in Christians and the way we speak against our brothers and sisters in Christ. Judging them is like judging the law, much like presuming tomorrow is not taking God’s will into consideration. After this paragraph, James will once again deal with wealthy people and chide them for how they treat the poor.
Dig Deeper
This section addresses speech, arrogance in planning, and ignoring God in your planning. As such, it has ties to the section on worldliness (James 4:1-10), speaking against your brother or sister in Christ (James 4:11-12), and the next section on how the rich are treating the poor (James 5:1-6).
James 4:13. James begins this section with an attention-getting “Come now.” He is going to address a group of people, this time differently than before. Usually, he addresses brothers and sisters. But this time, he is dealing with a specific group of people. These are the people who plan a business trip to make a profit. He characterizes the kind of speech they have about their planning.
James characterizes the speech of these business people and how they plan with four verbs in the future tense they start with “today or tomorrow,” and acknowledgment that it doesn’t really matter when they begin their travels. It may be that they will have to wait for a ship to be ready if they are going overseas. It shows that they are not concerned with the trip starts. It may also be part of James’s characterizing of their planning. The first verb is, “we will go.”. The part of this first sentence that is problematic is “this or that city.” James is not specific as to which city they will go to. It could be that they are choosing a destination last minute.
The second verb is “We will spend.” The verb is actually the word “do, make” but here it represents spending a year there. The third verb is “We will do business.” The last verb is “We will make a profit.” These business people are guaranteeing that they will do these four things. It is the equivalent of today’s businesses that have all kinds of plans and schemes on how to make sure they make money. I have seen commercials for companies that tell you they only make a profit in stocks and bonds if you make a profit. But they are making sure they will make a profit no matter what.
It is the deterministic picture of the Christian merchants’ planning that is problematic for James. They are guaranteeing things they have no control over. They are saying they will do things without fail. James may have been thinking about Jesus’s parable of the rich fool (Luke 12: 16-21). This man was extremely wealthy. His fields produced such a large harvest that he bothered himself with how to store it all.
He tore down the barns he had and build bigger ones to store the harvest. His sin was that he didn’t think of giving it away. He meant to hoard it all to himself and then retire, to quit and relax for the rest of his life. The rich man presumed tomorrow would come but God demanded his life from him before then. Jesus taught that our life doesn’t consist only of our possessions. We need to steward all of our resources, including our lives, which are a gift from God. All of his possessions meant nothing when judgment came.
Tell Me More
In this section, James talks to Christian merchants in his church. This paragraph connects to the next one in James 5:1-6 because James uses the same opener, “Come now.” He gives hope to this group that they can turn things around and stop arrogantly presuming upon tomorrow. James believes they can adjust their mindset to include thinking about God’s will and how God is involved in their planning.
However, in the next section in James 5:1-6, he does not hold out the same hope. Instead of gently addressing an issue with the rich, he will go full-blown apocalyptic on them. He chides and yells at them for how they treat the poor. We will see that in the next section of James, but I wanted to show a contrast between how James deals with these Christian merchants and how he will deal with the wicked rich.
James 4:14. James responds to this kind of thinking and planning. He says, “You do not know what will happen tomorrow.” It is likely these are Christian merchants who in practice have not considered their mortality and God’s will. They think they can do whatever they want whenever they want. They sound like they could live forever. But that is not the case.
He challenges these business people about their attitude and thinking they will live forever, he wants to remind them that they do not know what will happen tomorrow, let alone in a year. Some Bible versions have a question and statement while others just have a statement. His challenge about not knowing what life will bring reminds me of the course of a hymn we used to sing.
Many things about tomorrow
I don't seem to understand
But I know who holds tomorrow
And I know who holds my hand
”I Know Who Holds Tomorrow” by Emily Ann Roberts
No one but God knows when we will die. Only He has our days numbered. So, we cannot declare all the plans we have will not fail or have issues we did not plan for. It is more likely we will run into issues we did not plan. Such is the nature of life. James reminds these Christian merchants of these biblical truths.
After asking, “What is your life,” he offers the image that you are a vapor that appears for a short time and then vanishes. This is an illusion to the Old Testament (Psalm 39:5; 102:3; 103:13-15; 144:4; Proverbs 27:1; Ecclesiastes 9:11-12; Job 7:7; Isaiah 40:6-8; Hosea 13:3). It selected problem is not the exact quotation, but the idea originates from Scripture.
The concept of living for a very short time, even if you live for 70, 80, or more years, is a biblical concept. Even Jesus asks if you can add many years to your life by worrying (Matthew 6:27; Luke 12:25). The Bible also teaches the principle that our lives belong to God. He decides how long each of us lives. This is what James one Christian merchants to incorporate into their planning.
Let us be clear that James has nothing against planning for the future. In fact, the Bible talks about planning as a wise thing to do (Proverbs 6:6-8; 15:22; 16:3, 9;: 20:18; 21:5; 24:27; 27:23-24;; Luke 14:28-30;). The problem is not planning. It is leaving God out of your planning. It’s the refusal to recognize God’s sovereignty over your life and planning as if you will live forever or do whatever you want. You must first consider the frailty of life.
James 4:15. James offers a better way to approach planning for the future. He tells these Christian merchants that instead of this, they should say something else. But what is James referring to? It is either the four things they say they will do in James 4:13, or it is the verse that comes after this one. It makes more sense that since James has a problem with how they talk about their future plans that he is offering another approach to their four statements. He offers and alternatives to their boasts about their plans.
First, James has reminded the merchants that they are living as if their plans are ironclad and nothing can stop them from doing whatever they wish. Now, he gives them a way to include God in their plans. He says instead of their approach, they should say, “If the Lord wills.” This is not just a platitude, like saying, “in Jesus’s name” at the end of our prayer. Words mean nothing if we do not understand why we Satan. The goal here is to consider that God’s will is most important in our plans.
When we prioritize God’s will, we realize the true order of our life. We consider God’s will, and then we can say, “We will both live and do this or that selectively prioritize.” This puts everything in the proper order. We see that we only live because God wills it. Every breath we take is because God allows it.
After seeing that our life belongs to God and only He can grant us more life, we can make plans to do this or that. We acknowledge God in our life and that what to do what He wants us to do first. This is the best way to make plans. We honor God and realize Him first, and then our plans will fall into place.
Putting God first and acknowledging His will has practical applications for plans. Before filling in our schedule for the next day, week, or longer, we first asked the question, “What does God want me to do this week?” We seek God’s will. We wonder how we can glorify God in our plans. Leave space in your schedule for God to move in your life and through you to others. Leave ministry time, or at least time for divine appointments. Consider planning your spiritual disciplines and how you will interact with the Bible this week. You already know what you want to do, but what does God want you to do and how does He want to be involved in your life?
This is the purpose of not doing things before you consider, “If the Lord wills.” I know Christians who have inserted this in their speech with a talk about planning. That is not about practice. Remember that the goal of “if the Lord wills” concerns us thinking through our plans and incorporating what God wants from us, for us, and our planning. If you don’t say, “If the Lord wills,” you at least must be incorporating God’s will for you and people in your life into your plans. You are looking for ways to please the Lord and honor Him in your planning and acting.
James 4:16. James makes a third observation, one that is extremely dangerous. These Christian merchants are boasting about their plans. These boasts come from James 4:13 where he outlined the four approaches to planning. First, they planned as though they were invincible. Second, they did not include God’s will in their plans. Now there are boasting about their plans. The word for arrogance is plural, so it refers to the four approaches they took to their planning to go to a city, spend a year there, do business, and make a profit.
Arrogance and pride are major issues that cause people to falter in their plans. Most people logically plan for things to go wrong and not according to plan. The Bible talks about pride and arrogance (Proverbs 8:13; 11:2; 13:10; 16:5, 16-17, 19; 18:12; 21:4; 29:23; Isaiah 2:11-12; Daniel 4:37; Obadiah 3-4; Luke 18:9-14; Romans 12:3; Galatians 6:3; Philippians 2:3; James 4:6; 1 Peter 5:5; 1 John 2:16). It does not describe them as positive character traits. They always cause trouble.
Arrogance keeps a person from seeing the reality of the situation. Pride and arrogance deprive a person of basic reason. It causes you to think nothing can stop your plans. You do not put contingencies in your plans because you think nothing will go wrong. There is no plan B.
Then when something goes wrong, your plans are ruined. You get behind schedule. Stress sets in. And all this time your arrogant plan is failing, you do not ask for help. You don’t put God first or as part of your plan. You are not doing God's will. It reminds me of James’s image of the wind and waves causing the person who prays while doubting (James 1:6).
In a Word…
The Greek word for boast καυχάομαι (kauchaomai) means to boast or glory in something. It appears 37 times in the New Testament. James uses it twice (James 1:9; 4:16). The noun (καύχησις (kauchēsis) occurs 11 times in the New Testament, and only once in James. The Bible generally looks down on boasting. It is not an activity of a God-fearing person.
James 4:17. This wisdom saying seems to not fit the context at first. Some commentators say that it has nothing to do with this section on presuming upon tomorrow. But it does. James uses this saying to summarize his message in this short section. The wisdom saying says that a person who knows the right thing to do but does not do it sins. Many commentators point out that this is talking about the sin of omission. I believe James is talking about that, but it is about having the responsibility to follow through when you know what to do.
Sometimes I knew what I should do but was afraid to do it. I did not have the courage to follow through. The Holy Spirit continues to bring you. This is the course of action God wants me to take. It is almost like a broken record. Until I obey the Lord and do what I know I should do, He will continue to put it in front of me. I cannot move forward until I accomplish this task. Perhaps it is the same for you. I can feel the Holy Spirit impressing upon me that I must do it.
In the context of this passage, James is saying that these Christian merchants must plan according to God’s will and without arrogance, or they are sinning against the Lord. It is a serious charge. Jonah knew what the Lord wanted him to do, but he refused. He actually fled in the opposite direction of Nineveh. God had to force him to go to Nineveh by creating a storm that caused the Gentiles in the boat to throw him overboard. The giant fish did the rest, spitting him up on the shores of Nineveh. I would rather listen to God and do the right thing I know to do then go through an experience like that.
Tell Me More
Here are all the words used once in James 4:
- James 4:4 – φιλία -ας, ἡ; (philia) means affection or friendship. In James, it means friendship. It is a close association with someone. This word appears regularly in the Septuagint (36 times) and common in other Greek literature. Here, it is the choice to be a friend of the world or a friend of God. It is exclusive in this section.
- .James 4:5 – κενῶς (kenōs) means they were vanity, empty. It is a truly unique word, appearing in the Septuagint and once in the Apostolic Fathers. Here, it refers to Scripture not being in vain.
- James 4:5 – κατοικίζω (katoikizō) means settle or establish. It appears 45 times in the Septuagint and his numerous also in classical Greek literature. James uses it to refer to the Spirit God “causes to dwell” in us.
- James 4:9 – ταλαιπωρέω (talaipōreō) means misery, suffer hardship, suffer, endure. It appears 17 times in the Septuagint, is numerous in classical Greek literature, and appear several times in works like Josephus and Philo. James uses it to describe what the attitude of worldly Christians should be, to be miserable.
- James 4:9 – γέλως (gelōs) means laughter. It appears 20 times in the Septuagint, is most numerous in classical Greek literature, and used more regularly by James’s contemporaries like Philo and Josephus. It is likely James leads on the Old Testament for the wording about turning laughter into weeping.
- James 4:9 – μετατρέπω (metatrepō) means change, turned around. It is used once in the Septuagint and 8 times in Philo.
- James 4:9 – κατήφεια (katēpheia) means gloom, gloominess, and dejection. This is also part of James’s description of how worldly Christians should act. It is a word found in Josephus (12 times) and Philo (15 times). It is more numerous in classical Greek literature.
- James 4:12 – νομοθέτης (nomothetēs) means lawgiver, someone who lays down a code of laws. It is used twice in the Septuagint. It is a word used more in classical Greek literature and among James’s contemporaries like Josephus and Philo. James refers to God as Lawgiver and Judge.
What's James Saying?
James was aware of some Christian merchants in his church that may have correct doctrine but were living like atheists in their planning. They would plan business trips without taking into consideration the frailty of their lives. They were acting like they could not die, and they could deal with anything that would try to derail their plans. These merchants acted as if they were invincible and nothing could stop them.
James points out the frailty of life from the Old Testament background and reminds them that they do not know what tomorrow will bring. He is not against making plans for the future. We must make plans tentatively instead of firmly. He also raises the issue of God’s will. If God wills, we will live first, and then we can do this or that. We must be aware of God’s will before we make our plans and include Him in them.
We must watch out that we are not boasting in our plans because boasting will come to nothing. He lays down a principle that if we know what to do but don’t do it, we are sinning against God. Just like with judging others, we are taking His place and doing something with our plans that only God can do.
James's Themes
This section deals with merchants who are probably Christians, but are not living like Christians in their planning and traveling. James deals extensively with the wealthy throughout his letter (James 1:9-11; 2:1-12; 4:13-17; 5:1-6). In each section he deals with the wealthy and the poor, he has a different message. He does not look favorably or kindly toward the rich.
In the Bible
You can find sections of the Bible on the rich and poor. Some of the Proverbs deal with the wealthy and the poor (Proverbs 10:15; 11:28; 13:7-8, 23; 14:20-21, 31; 17:5; 18:11, 23; 19:4, 7, 17; 21:13; 22:2, 7, 9, 16, 22-23; 28:3, 6, 8, 11, 27; 23:4-5; 29:1, 7, 13; 30:8-9). Many Old Testament people believed God blessed people who are rich but looked down on the poor. People like Abraham and his sons, along with Job and others, were blessed because of God’s favor. However, God’s favor was not always about being wealthy. Some of the greatest Old Testament saints suffered greatly but were still favored by God.
The New Testament tends to address the rich as people who are not following God doing God’s will. Jesus had a lot to say to the wealthy and the poor (Matthew 5:3; 6:19-21, 24; 13:22; 19:22-24; 25:31-46; Mark 10:23-25; Luke 6:20-26; three:15-21; 33-34; 16:19-31; 21:1-4). The New Testament letters also speak of wealthy and poor people (1 Corinthians 16:1-2; 2 Corinthians 8:9, 13-15; 9:6-11; Galatians 2:10; Ephesians 4:28; Philippians 4:11-13; two Thessalonians 3:10-12; 1 Timothy 5:3-8; 6:6-10, 17-19; Hebrews 13:5; James 1:9-11; 2:1-7, 14-17; 5:1-6; 1 John 3:17-18). The poor tend to be treated as people God cares about. They have blessing in the future but not now. Much of the New Testament focuses on the future inheritance of heaven for the poor. The wealthy must enjoy their lives now because eternity may not be so great for them.
Wisdom for Today
This short section packs a powerful punch for all of us because we all presume certain things, like the next breath, the next minute, the next day, and so on. In fact, we build plans for that upcoming time. To not build any plans whatsoever would be bad stewardship in the other direction. But we must be very careful not to forget that we are on a mission for God, to fulfill His will in our lives and in our circles of influence.
We can have plans without ignoring our own mortality and God’s control and authority. Do you leave room for God in your day? As you go about your day, are you open to the Spirit’s leading? Are you prepared for a divine appointment with someone? We live for the One. Every breath that we take is a gift from God, and we need to put that life we live to good use, to God’s use. I’m not saying that everyone has to become a full-time minister. But How effective you are for God in your life right now.
Do you think about the Lord’s will in your life often? Do you take into account the possibilities of being His ambassador, His servant, Jesus with skin on to people desperate in need? I think we have all had moments where we have grieved the Holy Spirit by ignoring his promptings. But that should not happen if we consider our lives secondary to the call of God to do His will on the earth. So get out there and live that gift of life. Get out there and do God’s will. May everything you think, say, do, believe, and feel be motivated with the purpose of putting a smile on God’s face!
Ask yourself these questions:
- How do I know by my planning and the things I do that I am including God in it all?
- How can I include God and His will in my plans and daily activities?
- What actions can I take right now to incorporate God in my plans? Do I make foolproof plans or tentative ones? Do I pencil in my plans or write in appointments with ink?
- If I evaluate my life right now, and I doing the right thing or am I sinning against God in my planning and actions?
- Are there things I should be doing that I am not doing in my walk with Jesus? What are they? How can I start doing them in obedience to the Holy Spirit today?
Starter Prayer
Lord Jesus, I have been living and planning like I am invincible. I do not think about the consequences of my planning or the way I living. I am practically living like an atheist. Please forgive me and guide me in my planning and daily activities to glorify you, to do Your will, and not sin against You anymore. Help me to realize You are with me every day. Help me sense Your presence. Let me be a light to the world for You. In Your blessed and mighty name, amen.
